Metal Roofs vs Rubber Roofs: What’s the Difference?

Close Up View of Metal Roof From Underneath

Metal Roofs vs Rubber Roofs: What’s the Difference?

Despite having certain distinctions, metal and rubber roofing are both long-lasting systems. Your ability to recognize their distinctions and make an informed decision will be taught to you in this piece. Your roof is said to be “flat” if it has very little or no slope. If so, Edmonton’s most popular roofing system is a 2-ply torch-on or rubber membrane (EPDM). A metal or asphalt roofing system is not something we advise adopting.

Metal roofs vs rubber roofs


There have been metal roofs for a very long time. Modern rubber roofs, however, are a relatively recent development. Due to their outstanding durability and environmental friendliness, both are emerging roofing materials for residential structures. But how do the two differ from one another? We’ll discuss the distinctions between the two common roofing materials in this piece, focusing on their construction, aesthetics, and energy efficiency.

·       Material

The material is where rubber and metal roofs most obviously diverge. Both are environmentally friendly choices from start to finish because they are made from recycled materials and can be recycled after serving their purpose.

Contrary to metal roofs, rubber roofs are a relatively new invention. About 95% of the materials used to create the rubber roofing Jancon Exteriors provides are recycled. Our roofing products are made to lower the number of old tires dumped in landfills. In 2015 alone, the U.S. produced 246 million used tires, to be precise.

Traditional metal roofs are among the most resilient and long-lasting alternatives available because they are made of zinc, as you might see on buildings in Paris. Modern metal roofs, such as the ones we provide here at State Roofing, are built with a variety of metals for a more affordable alternative and incorporate galvanized steel to make them more durable than industry norms.

No roofing material has a clear advantage over the others in this discussion. Rubber roofs are not less durable just because they haven’t been around as long as metal roofs. Personal preference is the deciding factor.

·       Durability

Making sure your roof is in good condition is crucial to keeping your house dry and safe since it serves as your home’s first line of defense against the elements. In this instance, there are differences in the durability of various roofing materials. For instance, despite being incredibly affordable, the ever-popular asphalt shingles only have a 25-year lifespan. They have a shorter lifespan and are more prone to mold and algae because they are porous and absorb water.

Conversely, rubber roofs are constructed with durability in mind. Durability was also a consideration in the design of metal roofs. Similar to rubber roofs, metal roofs require almost no upkeep. For instance, standing seam metal roofs feature material seams that are above the roof. Elevating the seams helps safeguard the material’s most typical weak spot, the seam itself.

Here are a few advantages of the rubber roofing that Jancon Exteriors provides:

  • Provides a tight fit to keep out rain thanks to tongue-and-groove tiles that interlock.
  • Resistant to surface wear like splitting, cracking, curling, etc.
  • provides moss and algae protection

·       Aesthetics

The roof of your house needs to look attractive in addition to being strong. There are now many different styles of metal roofs to choose from, including those that mimic the appearance of traditional shakes and shingles like ironwood metal roofs and metal shakes. Traditional metal roofs all had a similar appearance.


Rubber roofs provide excellent aesthetic options as well. Rubber roofs are offered in a range of colors to complement the appearance of your home and are made to seem like classic shakes and shingles. For instance, the (mention your product name here) was made to flawlessly imitate the chiseled-edge slate and could easily be mistaken from a distance for a real slate roof.

Which Should You Choose?

In the field of residential roofing, both rubber and metal roofs are on the rise. The material that these two roofing materials are constructed of is what distinguishes them most from one another. While metal roofs can save utility expenses during the warmer months, rubber roofs are excellent at insulating a home. Both types of roofing materials have a very long lifespan, require little upkeep, and are resistant to mold and algae. Furthermore, these materials precisely mimic the appearance of conventional shakes and shingles without the heavy maintenance bother. There isn’t a single better roofing choice when it comes to rubber and metal roofs when all of these considerations are taken into account.